The Complicated Morality of Pulling Out
After using fabricated evidence and even outright lies to justify invading Iraq, the United States has since pulled out. And the violence continues. Nearly 8,000 civilians were killed last year in bloody sectarian/revolutionary violence. Now the United States is preparing to pull out of Afghanistan. Indeed, President Barack Obama is talking about moving up the time table and even threatening to remove all U.S. troops by year’s end, in part because of his endless frustrations with Afghan President Muhammad Karzai. Obama’s advisers reportedly want him to leave about 10,000 troops behind to help battle Al Qaueda and Taliban insurgents. Whether this is a real threat by Obama or just diplomatic brinksmanship is almost irrelevant to some degree; this year or next, the United States will pull out all or nearly all of its troops from Afghanistan, more than a decade after invading it. Whether one originally supported or opposed the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan (I vehemently opposed the former and had mixed feelings about the latter), the current issue confronting the United States has to do with the aftermath of invasion, not its impetus: To what degree does the United States have a moral obligation to help nations it has invaded? And how much of that obligation is tied to the endemic violence that U.S. invasions helped unleash?
The Complicated Morality of Pulling Out Read More »